Community Board 6 Manhattan

Community Board Meeting Minutes

July 2000 Meeting Minutes

CITY OF NEW YORK
COMMUNITY BOARD SIX MANHATTAN
886 United Nations Plaza, Ste.308
New York, NY 10017
Phone:(212) 319-3750 Fax:(212) 319-3772



FULL BOARD MEETING MINUTES
Wednesday, July 12, 2000
NYU MEDICAL CENTER
FIRST AVENUE


HON. Martin J. Barrett, Chair


ATTENDANCE


Members answering first roll call:

Arcaro, Barrett, Bing, Buchwald, Disman, Doukas, Dresselhuys, Frank, Friedman, Garodnick, Gelber, Herskovitz, Hirsch, Hollander, Imbimbo, Judge, Kaplan, Lynn, Martino, McGinn, McIntosh, Milton, Papush, Portnoy, Ross, Rusz, Schachter, Schwartz, Sepersky, Shaw, Simmelkjaer, Swanson, Taylor (Dean Clarke), Taylor (Mark Adams), West, Winfield


Members answering second roll call:

Arcaro, Barrett, Bing, Buchwald, Disman, Doukas, Dresselhuys, Frank, Friedman, Garodnick, Gelber, Herskovitz, Hirsch, Hollander, Imbimbo, Judge, Kaplan, Lynn, Martino, McGinn, McIntosh, Milton, Monterossa, Oddo, Papush, Portnoy, Ross, Rubin, Rusz, Schachter, Schwartz, Sepersky, Shaw, Simmelkjaer, Swanson, Taylor (Dean Clarke), Taylor (Mark Adams), Tu, West, Winfield


Excused

Collins, Reiss

Absent (Members not present or not answering one or both roll calls):

Alcamo, Angelakos, Cohen, Emerrnan, Levinson, Luntz, Monterossa, Oddo. Rosen, Rubin, Tu, Zeichner

Guests signing in: Michael Rabinowitz, Asm. Richard Gottfried's Office; Carol Ozgen; Aliza Gebiner; Marnie
Glassman; Ann Duggan; Noelle Tutinjian, Liz Krueger for State Senate; Celeste Dubosky; Andrew Ashkenase,
Asm. John Ravitz's Office; Brian J. Miller; Linda Nevins; Steve Wygoda; Jessica Lappin, CM Gifford Miller's
Office; Phil Craft, Rep. Carolyn Maloney's Office; Tom McGrath, Black Sheep Restaurant; Richard J. Eyen, SAC;
Lucy Mayo, Senator Tom Duane's Office.



Call to Order

Martin J. Barrett, Chair, announced that the next Full Board Meeting would be in September, unless there is a pressing Land Use issue that would require the Board to meet in August.

Adoption of the Agenda

Mr. Barrett announced the changes to the agenda and called for its adoption. By a voice vote, the amended agenda was adopted.

PUBLIC SESSION

Jessica Lappin reported that CM Gifford Miller sent a letter to Parks Commissioner Henry Stem supporting CB6's resolution to name a park after Jeff Stull. Copies of the letter were made available.

Phil Craft reported that Congress Member Carolyn Maloney was on CSPAN earlier that evening. She spoke in opposition to the Foreign Aid Bill that has a gag rule that forbids U.S. funds to be appropriated to international family planning programs. Mr. Craft also announced that Rep. Maloney secured $3 million for the Second Avenue Subway. She also wrote a letter to Lawrence Reuter, President of the MTA who has proposed revisions to the M57 crosstown bus route. The letter requests that the matter be postponed until Autumn, allowing the public to weigh
the potential impact and to comment. Ted Lynn asked Mr. Craft about the status of helicopter noise study that the Congress Member helped make possible. Mr. Craft said that they are frustrated with the FAA's announcement to move forward without conferring with the Representative. She will press for opportunities for public comment.

Assembly Member John Ravitz reported that one of the most important bills passed in the last few days of the session was the Sexual Assault Reform Act. He said that the Act does not accomplish as much as they wanted but
it will give DAs more to work with. A number of anti-gun bills also passed including a ban on assault weapons, a demand for trigger locks, DNA forensics for bullets, and more money for gun education. Asm. Ravitz reported that a school safety bill passed along with other anticrime legislation. He said that he would continue to push for second opportunity schools for disruptive children. The Assembly Member reported that funding has been secured for Friends of Dag Hammarskjold to continue upkeep and for Sutton Area Community for beautification. The 17th Precinct also received funding for the "Young Ambassadors Club." The Club consists of children of U.N. officials and the at-risk youth they mentor. He thanked the Mayor's Office and Detectives Frank Bogucki and Jim Kelly at the 17th for their assistance with the Club. Asm. Ravitz announced that there would not be a Trump CAC meeting until September. The schedule he recently received from Bovis Construction projects the 73rd Floor would be completed by August 21st. He reported that a concrete slab fell a few weeks ago. Fortunately, no one was hurt. Extra netting has been put around the cement mixing machines on the floors above 60th. He said that the Buildings Department served violations and inspected the site for four consecutive days after the incident. They will continue to monitor it closely. He urged everyone to contact him if problems with the site arise. Lyle Frank asked if there were any updates on the Trump lawsuit. The Assembly Member said that he had not heard of any. Peter Doukas asked how many violations have been served on the site. Asm. Ravitz said that there was just one other that took place in the early stages of construction. Betty Schwartz asked if there were other incidents. Asm. Ravitz said wind carried some small items off the building a few months ago. As a result, 100 UN Plaza now has a shed in place. Mark Adams Taylor asked whether discretionary funds, similar to member items, were available for
capital projects for the district. The Assembly Member said that there were and that Senate Leader Bruno, Speaker
Silver and Governor Pataki were negotiating. Speaker Silver would decide on the various allocations thereafter.

Deanne D'Aloia reported that Council Member Lopez secured funds for the district and a grantee list was in the newsletter that Ms. D'Aloia brought that evening. She also said that the Council Member is looking into why the Council has approved a $1,300 per megawatt Con Ed cap when the Public Service Commission recommended a $1,000 per megawatt cap. Ms. D'Aloia reported that CM Lopez is trying to do something about the rats in the district in light of the reports at Baruch houses. She has sent letters to hospitals in the district to survey their pest
control needs. Ms. D'Aloia reported that the City Council recently formed a Select Committee on Pest Control that scheduled a hearing for July 24th. She also said that CM Lopez wrote to the MTA proposing an additional
entrance for the L train station at First Avenue. She said that the overcrowding at the current exit on the east side
of the Avenue is dangerous. Assembly Member Sanders has been active on this issue as well. Ms. D'Atola also reported that the Council Member opposes the franchise bus layover proposed for 15th Street and Avenue C.

Mike Rabinowitz from Assembly Member Gottfried's office reported that the Physician Profiling bill passed after three years in Committee. Also, the Assembly passed legislation to increase the Child Care Credit for all families earning less than $65,000.

Kevin Bargard spoke about the proposed bus layovers in Stuyvesant Town. He said that, as a father of three, a member of the PC/SV board, and a coach for towns that utilize the field by the proposed layover location, he is concerned about the health and safety of the children in the neighborhood. Mr. Bargard urged the Board to vote against layover in that area.

Sam Azadian, representing the Diocese of the Armenian Church, asked the Board to support the Street Activity Application before the Board that evening. Mr. Azadian said that the Church has held the One World fair every
year since 1973.

Richard Eyen, the Executive Vice President of SAC, spoke in regard to the M57 layover. He cited his credentials, that he recently served as Chair of a Transportation Committee for SAC. Mr. Eyen said that MTA told him and
others that the discussion on the M57 would be postponed and a ridership study would be conducted, per CB6's
request. Despite recent queries, the MTA announced presentations were scheduled with less than two weeks notice. The proposal suggests removing the M57 from the lower part of Sutton Place and the layover would be moved to
60th Street, with no service below 57th Street. To Mr. Eyen's knowledge, the only elected official that received notification was Rep. Charles Rangel from the West Side. Carol Pieper said that the office received notification
and it was forwarded to the Committee Chair. Mr. Eyen said that, while that may be true, no elected officials from
the East Side were contacted. He believes that this was a political tactic to ease West Side tensions over having too many layovers. Mickey Egeth added that the Committee was promised a walkthrough with the MTA. She wanted
to know if Mr. Eyen attended such a walkthrough. He said he did.

Carol A. Schachter read the roll call. See APPENDIX A.

PUBLIC HEARINGS

LAND USE AND LANDMARKS

1. Revisions of Madison Square Rezoning proposal

2. Revisions of Department of City Planning proposal to amend the zoning map on Lexington Avenue between East 54th Street and East 57th Street

In Edward Rubin's absence, John Pettit West III asked if anyone wanted to come forward to comment on either Land Use hearings. No one did.

TRANSPORTATION

1. Franchise bus layover on East 15th Street between FDR and Avenue C

Lou Sepersky said that Andrew Hollander of DOT was supposed to be present to speak but he was not. The hearing was canceled.


BUSINESS AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS

1. Application (#1032571) for a revocable consent for a new unenclosed sidewalk cafe from Maurello, Inc., 447 Third Avenue (East 30th-31st Streets) with 8 tables and 16 seats

Tim McGinn introduced the Maurello application and the architect, Joseph Scapiara. The original application had an 8-foot setback from the curb. The Committee recommended 9 feet, and the restaurant returned with revised drawings that evening. Mr. Scapiara explained that the cafe itself would be 6 feet wide with only 8 tables. John Pettit West said that the Community Board guidelines require 10 feet clearance on Avenues. He asked if the cafe would be on the midblock. Mr. Scapiara said that the restaurant is located just off the corner, adjacent to Moonstruck's enclosed cafe. Mr. West said that there have been problems where the wait staff tend to go onto the sidewalk when the aisle is in the center of tables. The owner said that the wait staff would have two exits. Sylvia Friedman said that it would be better to reduce the number of tables and have one row. The owner said that reducing the tables would not be profitable. Mr. West said that the layout would be improved if there was a path for the wait staff between the tables and the railing, and that fewer tables would require a smaller fee. Steve Portnoy asked if the Committee had any opposition. Mr. McGinn said that there was none. Ms. Friedman asked how much space was allotted for the wait staff. The owner said two feet. Mr. West said that three feet is needed
for handicap accessibility. The owner said that they would try to incorporate the suggestions offered that evening.

2. Application for a revocable consent for a Street Activity permit from The Black Sheep Restaurant on behalf of the NYPD Widows and Orphans Fund on Saturday, September 16th on East 38 th Street between 2nd and 3rd Avenues

Carol Schachter introduced the application by The Black Sheep Restaurant for an event to benefit the citywide NYPD Widows and Orphans Fund. Tom McGrath, owner of the restaurant and Officer John Flynn, a member
of the fund from came forward. Officer Flynn explained that the Fund is a 50lc(3) and does not actively solicit as other police-related charities do. He said that all of the funds go directly to families of officers killed on duty.
They have zero administrative costs. He named a few officers including P.O. Anthony Sanchez of the 13th Precinct who was murdered a three years ago. Officer Flynn said that there are about 85 widows and 160-or so kids who would benefit. He described some of the recreational activities and grant opportunities that the Fund sponsors. He said that Mr. McGrath reached out to the Fund.

PUBLIC SESSION continued

Senator Roy Goodman reported that the Investigation Committee is looking into legislation to protect women
from violence. One of the measures includes spousal abuse. He said that officers are being trained to recognize abuse and are required to file reports that may be used against the abuser. The Senator said millions of dollars
have been secured to improve equipment in a number of emergency rooms and hospitals. As one of the first State legislators to appropriate funding for the AIDS Advisory Council, he was pleased to report that more funds have been made available for AIDS research. He also said that pharmaceutical benefits are now included in health insurance for approximately 900,000 children. He also said that libraries that had funds cut a few years ago
would be receiving funding this year.

Senator Tom Duane expressed his enthusiasm over the hate crimes legislation that was signed into law by the Governor earlier that week. He said that documentation and recording of crimes will be important. The Senator
also reported that he and a Senator from Utica are working on getting legislation for Work-Study and Internships. He urged people to contact the Governor about that initiative which would help level the playing field. The
Senator said that the Taxi and Limousine Commission is moving toward a plan for more handicap accessible taxi cabs. He also reported that he has met with the court-appointed monitor who will oversee the New York Apple Tours' (NYAT) operations until the outcome of the permanent revocation case. He said that he is committed to working to ensure that either NYAT improves or is shut down. The Senator mentioned that he was also interested
in the developments on the Bellevue campus. Betty Schwartz said that EDC has narrowed down three proposals and NYU's application appears to be favored. Sen. Duane also said that he will be working on a State proclamation for lrene Peveri to recognize the works he has done for the community. Bill Oddo asked if it was possible to obtain federal funds to work with Big Apple Tours so that they would use better vehicles. The Senator does not feel that he can trust them at this point. He said that he heard that Greyhound may be getting federal funds for cleaner buses
and that he was impressed with how the Governor is dealing with Big Apple Tours.

BUSINESS SESSION

Adoption of the minutes for May 10, 2000.

By a voice vote, the minutes adopted as amended.

Report from the Chair

Martin J. Barrett reminded everyone of the upcoming election for Board officers. Mr. Barrett reported that the
Nominating Committee has met once. Nominations from the floor may be made at the September meeting. Voting
will take place in October and posts will change in November. Mr. Barrett said that a number of Board Members
approached him, and there was a brief discussion at Executive Committee, about the conduct of Members toward
speakers. Mr. Barrett said that undiplomatic behavior would not be tolerated and those who are verbally abusive
would not be recognized. He reminded everyone about orientation for new members the following evening. He
also announced that mentors have been assigned.

District Manager's Report

Carol Pieper reported that the status of the Board office move has progressed but nothing has been finalized.
Ms. Pieper also reported that there would be five TV/film shoots in the district that week. She explained that when she is notified by the Mayor's Office of Film, Theatre and Broadcasting, she immediately contacts the production companies to verify that they have sent letters to the residents of surround buildings. Ms. Pieper also
announced that recycling for the district reached 33% in April, the latest report, and 1st place has been reclaimed.

Treasurer's Report

Beatrice Disman said that there was nothing to report that month.

Borough President's Report

Noah Pfefferblit reported on the allocations for the 200l capital budget. As announced a few months earlier, $350,000 for the Stuyvesant Cove project has been formally appropriated. The biology labs at Baruch College
received $217,000 in an ongoing effort to improve facilities. Also, $60,000 was given to upgrade equipment at Repertorio Espanol. The Borough President has also committed $250,000 each year for the next four years for the construction of the Second Avenue subway. Funding has also been secured for a number of other items such as HHC clinics, schools, tree plantings, etc. Mr. Pfefferblit also announced that the Borough President has unveiled a hotline to report rat complaints, 1-800-RAT-1550. In addition to reporting the findings to the Department of
Health, the data will be used to develop approaches for outreach and coordination with other agencies. He said that there have been some technical proposals for remedying rat problems at construction and demolition sites. Mr. Pfefferblit said that he would keep the Board apprised. Peter Doukas asked if there were any West Nile Virus updates particularly in regard to spraying insecticide. Mr. Pfefferblit said that he was unaware of any beyond what has been reported by the local news. Carol Pieper said that the Department of Health has kept the Board Office apprised of their actions. Michael Hirsch asked about the status of collecting Census data. Mr. Pfefferblit said
that there was a task force and there have been efforts to reach out to those with limited English proficiency. Sherman Hollander asked about the Asian Longhorned Beetle. Mr. Pfefferblit asked if there have been reports in the district. Carol Pieper said there were none. Martin Barrett said there were some reported in Central Park.

COMMITTEE REPORTS

LAND USE AND LANDMARKS

lb. Proposed Madison Square Park Area Rezoning District (C00063IZMY)

Edward Rubin reported the proposal had not changed from the version the Board reviewed and voted on in April. He explained that map changes must go through a formal Uniform Land Use Review Procedure and that, since the City Council would not meet the July deadline, the Department of City Planning resubmitted the same application. for a new clock. The Unified Bulk Program and map changes would then be reviewed at the same time.

WHEREAS, Community Board Six in April 2000 voted to support this application; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six reaffirms its resolution of April 2000 in support of the application.

PASSED: 37 in favor, 1 opposed, and 0 Abstentions

I C. Amendment of rezoning along Lexington Avenue from East 54th Street to East 57th Street from C5-2A to C5-2.5 (C00063IZMY)

Edward Rubin explained that this reapplication incorporates the Board's recommendations for removing the one-FAR bonus plaza and street wall continuation on the side streets. The resolution reinforces these points.

WHEREAS, CB6 in April 2000 voted to support this application with two stipulations:

1) That a one FAR plaza bonus be eliminated; and
2) That the street wall be continued into the side streets; and

WHEREAS, the Department of City Planning has amended their application to eliminate the plaza bonus,
and extend the street wall continuity to the side streets; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that CB6 supports the application.

PASSED: 37 in favor, I opposed, and 0 abstentions

1d. Proposed Continuation of a Variance Allowing Transient Parking--300 East 56th St.

Edward Rubin said that the resolution for the parking facility was self-explanatory and well written.

WHEREAS, the 32 story apartment house at 300 East 56th Street (1048 Second Avenue, and 303 East 55th Street) was granted a variance in 1975 for a term of 15 years, and which was renewed in 1991 for an additional ten (10) years, to allow 100 unused parking spaces (of 300 spaces constructed) for transient parking; and

WHEREAS, this building is partly in a C 1-9 district, with the remainder in an R-8 zoning district, and is
also in the Special Transit Land Use District along Second Avenue, all in Community Board Six, Manhattan; and

WHEREAS, for these 25 years the occupants of the 367 apartment units have had the prerogative to recapture any of the 100 parking spaces they might need; and

WHEREAS, there is both retail and professional office use of the commercial space in this building; and

WHEREAS, additional conditions were attached to the variance, which included conforming to a drawing submitted to the Department of Buildings October 18, 1974 conforming to all other applicable laws, rules
and regulations and appropriate amendment of the certificate of occupancy; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, Community Board Six, Manhattan, offers no objection to a ten-year extension of a variance
to permit the use of 100 of the 300 parking spaces at 300 East 56th Street, at Second Avenue 1048 Second Avenue, and 303 East 55th Street, for transient use, subject to the following conditions:

The building comply with the zoning regulations for a C 1-9 district, and/or R-8
and the Special Transit Land Use District along Second Avenue, as appropriate; and

The occupants of the 367 apartment units retain the prerogative of recapture of any of the
100 parking spaces they might, need; and

The stipulations to the variance, which include conforming to the drawings submitted
to the Department of Buildings October 18, 1974; conforming to all other applicable laws,
rules and regulations, and the appropriate amendment of the certificate of occupancy continue,
and each continues to be observed in both letter and spirit.

PASSED: 38 in Favor, 0 Opposed, and 1 Abstention

le. A Variance Application to Legalize a Commercial Use as well as an Application for a Special Permit
to permit a Physical Culture Establishment in the Cellar at 314-322 East 52nd Street, Manhattan.

Edward Rubin explained that the skin care clinic has existed for about 30 years. They are asking for a variance because they do not have permission to use the space as a skin clinic. The Committee took into consideration that the clinic has been popular with neighbors, and there has been no opposition. The only recommendation the Committee made was that, since there are steps down to the entrance, it should be made handicap accessible.

WHEREAS, the application is pursuant to a change of use variance to legalize a current commercial use as well as a special permit application to permit a physical culture establishment in the cellar of 314-322 E. 52nd Street; and

WHEREAS, the current use, a skin care clinic, has been in operation at the premises since 1967; and

WHEREAS, the clinic serves approximately 200 persons daily; and

WHEREAS, the clinic has no access for the handicapped; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six has no objection to the applications provided that the applicant be required, as a condition of approval, to provide handicapped access to the premises.

PASSED: 37 Favor, 2 Opposed, and 0 Abstentions



1f. BSA (1070-84BZ) - Extend Term of Variance at 234 E. 58th Street

Edward Rubin reported that the restaurant has been in business for 15 years. The lawyer who was handling the
application has worked with the Board over the years on other matters. Mr. Rubin reported that the Committee in
caucused earlier in the evening and decided to support the application for five years.

WHEREAS, the applicant proposes to extend the term of an existing variance at the Board of Standards and Appeals to Permit a Restaurant Use at the First Floor; and

WHEREAS, the applicant does not seek to increase the previously approved degree of non conformance permitted by the variance; and

WHEREAS, the variance was granted fifteen years ago, and

WHEREAS, no complaints regarding this use were registered with Community Board Six.

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six has no objection to the granting of a variance for a term of five years.

PASSED: 38 in Favor, 0 Opposed, and I Abstention

1g. Extension onto the sidewalk at 250 East 54 th Street, The Mondrian.

Edward Rubin said that the physical culture establishment came to the Committee and said that they 'found' a few extra thousand square feet by reexamining the existing file drawings. They submitted an application to build a 10-
foot extension on Second Avenue. The Committee suspected that the application was for an alternate setback
which the applicant denied any knowledge of. When the Committee asked to look at the applicant's zoning sheets, they sent some material but the important information was omitted. CB6 passed a resolution requesting the Board
of Standards and Appeals look at the plans, but the BSA ignored the Board's suggestion and approved the
application. With great persistence, Lou Sepersky with the assistance of John West, was able to get the zoning calculations and found that indeed it was a plaza based on an alternate setback. The resolution before the Board
that evening requested the Department of Buildings revoke the Certificate of Occupancy for The Mondrian. Mr. Rubin said the Board should aggressively pursue this matter. The resolution should be sent to the Mayor's Office, City Planning, Department of Buildings, Board of Standards and Appeals and elected officials.

WHEREAS, The Mondrian, formerly Le Grand Palais, 250 East 54 Street, at the southwest comer of 54 Street and Second Avenue in Community Board Six built in 1991 with a plaza or widened sidewalk along
the entire Second Avenue east frontage of the building; and

WHEREAS, when the Equinox Fitness Club replaced the New York Health and Racquet Club as the
operator of the physical culture establishment occupying parts of the first floor, first floor mezzanine, cellar and subcellar, the premises were enlarged to occupy most of the plaza or widened sidewalk along Second Avenue; and

WHEREAS, In January 1999 Community Board Six adopted a resolution questioning the legality of expanding the building into this plaza or widened sidewalk and requesting the Department of City Planning and the Board of Standards and Appeals to investigate the matter; and

WHEREAS, a review of the file at the Department of Buildings indicates that the plaza or sidewalk
widening was a "front open area" required by Section 33-442 of the Zoning Resolution, which allows a
lesser initial setback (ten feet instead of 15 feet) and a steeper sky exposure plane (7.6 to 1 instead of 5.6 to
1) (See sheet ZC I approved by DoB 29 May 1990), resulting in a building that rises closer to and higher along Second Avenue and does not indicate any approved change thereto; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six requests that the Department of Buildings revoke the Certificate
of Occupancy of 250 East 54 Street, The Mondrian and direct that the enlargement of the east frontage of
the building be removed and the plaza or sidewalk widening be restored.

PASSED: 39 in Favor, 0 Opposed, and 0 Abstentions

Edward Rubin reported that the Committee received an application for a proposed text change that would affect
the new Museum of Modern Art. Since a very small portion of the district would be affected by the proposed text change, the Committee decided not to take action. A one sentence letter to Richard Barth that was drafted by a
lawyer from Rosenman & Colin would be sent as a formality. Mr. Rubin also reported on the EDC's presentation
on the Bellevue RFEI responses. They said that some of the proposals from nonprofits included housing and other suggestions to preserve the psychiatric building. It appears that EDC has tentatively selected NY Medical School
to develop the site. The project would be built in three phases. There would be 600,000 square feet for
commercial biotechnical use including a biomedical library and housing for post-doctoral students. The Committee has concerns about the proposal, including the urban design, community issues such as access from the street, to
the waterfront; its connection to Bellevue Hospital and NYU Medical Center. Mr. Rubin said that the EDC representatives were vague about what will happen to Bellevue. The Committee questions whether a medical
school can handle the development of a $250 million construction endeavor. If this space is intended for
commercial biotechnical use, Mr. Rubin questioned why an RFD would not be appropriate. It would attract other groups that might be able to develop the land better. It is also unclear whether only NYU would benefit or if
Bellevue would as well. Mr. Rubin said that EDC said this was preliminary and that they would return with
updates. Ellen lmbimbo added that nothing has been said about the 850 men in the shelter who will be displaced. She recommends that short-term plans should be devised to help the men. Beatrice Disman asked if Mr. Rubin
could elaborate on the other two proposals that Betty Schwartz mentioned earlier. Mr. Rubin said that EDC said
that they would share the other two proposals. Ms. Imbimbo asked if it was legitimate to have private institutions
use public property. Mr. Rubin explained that the legal process would involve solid evidence that Bellevue does
not need the property, and the City may sell it and it would be rezoned. Antol Herskowitz said that, in the past,
EDC has not replied to the Board in a timely manner and he suggested that there should be a record of the Board's concerns. Mr. Rubin said that he is not convinced that EDC is concerned with the community. He said that he thinks that the Board should take the step of contacting elected officials. Frank Scala asked whether Mr. Rubin
knew of any plans for the parking garage. Mr. Rubin said that part of the original RFEI was to alienate some of
the existing parking at Bellevue and that the new development would replace a portion of the space.

LANDMARKS SUBCOMMITTEE

Gary Papush reported that the old Russell Sage Foundation building on Lexington Avenue and 314 East 53rd Street were given landmark status recently. Mr. Papush explained that the Board addressed the Sage building in a
resolution on the Gramercy Historic District. He also shared some new information on 314 East 53 rd Street that was in a recent New York Times article. It was built just after the Civil War and the wooden building next door was landmarked in 1968. The developer, Harry Macklowe, acquired 314 East 53 d Street and had intended to tear it
down. Mr. Macklowe was persuaded to give up the property and the building was saved. Peter Doukas asked
about 931 First Avenue. Mr. Papush said that the Buildings Department and EDC have resolved the issue.

TRANSPORTATION

2a. Proposed Express/Franchise bus layover on East 15th Street between FDR and Avenue C

Lou Sepersky introduced the resolution.
WHEREAS, the New York City Department of Transportation has proposed the creation of a franchise/express bus layover parking area on East 15th Street between the Franklin D. Roosevelt Drive Service Road and Avenue C, in Community Board 6, Manhattan to accommodate, on a rotating basis, a maximum of 10 parked buses; and

WHEREAS, these buses currently layover on streets around and/or near Madison Square Park, Madison Avenue, 23rd to 26th streets; and

WHEREAS, the request for the relocation of some of the layover parking for the buses was made to the Mayor's Office by the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, owner of I Madison Avenue; and

WHEREAS, the north side of East 15th Street, at this location, is the perimeter of playing fields used by
several youth activities programs, and for active athletic areas; and

WHEREAS, the proposed layover location is now posted for alternate side parking and is used by residents of Stuyvesant Town and other area residents and by members of the New York City Police Department attached to the Police Academy and 13th Precinct; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board 6, Manhattan opposes the creation of a layover parking area for franchise/express buses on East 15th Street between the Franklin D. Roosevelt Service Road and Avenue C, within Community Board Six, Manhattan, because of the threat these buses pose to young people using the play area and the increased pollution which will be generated; and

BE IT FURTHER

RESOLVED, that the loss of 15th Street for alternate side parking will pose a serious dislocation to a community which has already lost a substantial amount of parking space.

PASSED: 38 in Favor, 0 Opposed, and 1 Abstention

2e. Proposed Rerouting of the M57 Bus and the loss of Two Bus Stops

Lou Sepersky announced that the Committee decided to delete the fifth "whereas" from the draft resolution.

WHEREAS, the M57 route of New York City Transit's (NYCT) bus service now serves stops on Sutton Place at East 55th Street and 55h Street at First Avenue, both within Community Board Six, Manhattan; and

WHEREAS, NYCT is in the process of adding a layover on the east bound service of that route, (now proposed to be on East 60th Street, at the Southwestern comer of York Avenue); and

WHEREAS, NYCT is proposing elimination of these M57 stops by having the buses turn west from York Avenue/Sutton Place directly to East 57th Street, reducing the availability of bus service to residents south of 55th Street and east of First Avenue; and

WHEREAS, NYCT has provided current ridership data for the M57, Eastern Terminal Check Point shows a growth from 359 riders in March to May 3 74 riders; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six, Manhattan demands the retention of New York City Transit's (NYCT) M57 bus service at Sutton Place at East 55th Street and East 55th Street at First Avenue; and
BE IT FURTHER

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six further demands NYCT halt its review and proposed realignment of the M57 route, including a scheduled "informational item" on the July 17 agenda of the New York City Transit Committee of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority Board, until such time as Community Board Six, and other representatives of the affected communities, can be fully and consistently involved in an open and participatory decision making process.

PASSED: 38 in Favor, 0 Opposed, and I Abstention

2f. Proposed Articulated Bus Stops

Bill Oddo suggested that the service oriented issues should be addressed after the articulated buses have been purchased. Since the purchasing process takes a long time, the Board should concentrate on replacing the current buses and should remove the passage in the resolution before the Board that evening regarding service issues. Mr. Oddo said, further, that the MTA representatives did not address service concerns and did not promote the
articulated buses well at the Committee meeting. He recommended that the Board support a 1-for-1 bus exchange, have better MTA reps, and not implement usage of the buses until service issues are addressed. Sherman
Hollander said that, in his experience, the articulated buses do take a long time and that more buses are needed. Someone else said that parking spaces would be taken and the waits would take longer. Ted Lynn said that the resolution requests a moratorium for a few short months before more buses are ordered or bought. Michael Hirsch offered a friendly amendment to include Bill Oddo's suggestions. John Pettit West III recommended the words "additional purchase" be removed from the first "Resolved." Mr. Sepersky conferred with the Committee. Mr.
West's friendly amendment was adopted. Betty Schwartz proposed a friendly amendment to address backups. Mr. Sepersky said that that issue was separate and would be addressed at the next meeting. Gary Papush said that
he agreed with Mr. Hollander and Mr. Lynn that the increased length of bus stops would decrease parking space in commercial areas. Mary Elizabeth Rusz said that she rode on an articulated bus and was impressed with it. However she did agree that service for the 23rd Street line was inadequate. Ellen Imbimbo offered a friendly amendment to add a reference to a one-to-one exchange. The Committee accepted the amendment.

WHEREAS, articulated buses are considerably longer than standard buses operated by New York City Transit (NYCT) and have a larger number of seats on each such articulated bus; and

WHEREAS, the (east - west) crosstown streets are especially congested (i.e. 23rd Street); and

WHEREAS, this introduction of articulated buses on a route has been coincident with a reduction of the number of bus runs (three articulated buses for each four conventional buses), making possible a reduction
in work force by NYCT; and

WHEREAS, this reduction in the number of runs increases the waiting time (headway) between buses; and

WHEREAS, the increased headway leads to an increase in the number of riders boarding at each stop, thus increasing the amount of time a bus spends (dwell time) at each bus stop; and

WHEREAS, this additional dwell time, combined with increased headway on a particular route, regardless of the larger number of seats is, in fact, a reduction in service; and

WHEREAS, to accommodate the larger buses proposed for service on the M23 (23rd Street, river to river),
NYCT is putting forward a proposal to increase the length of certain bus stops (East Bound: Third Avenue- 31'; FDR Service Road at 20th Street - 110'. West Bound: 23rd Street at Lexington Avenue -49') all in Community Board Six, Manhattan; now


THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that New York City Transit delay the one to one exchange, and the conversion of the M23 and/or other routes, to articulated buses until it is determined what the impact of such changes in headways and bus capacity of each specific route is on:
* customer service
* speed and ability to sustain scheduled service
* impact on curb usage by the longer bus stops
* impact on traffic of the longer buses
* review other routes with greater capacity needs
BE IT FURTHER

RESOLVED, that NYCT separate the desire to reduce its work force from the issues involved with ridership and capacity needs of particular routes and communities.

PASSED: 38 in Favor, 1 Opposed, and 0 Abstentions

BUSINESS AND GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS

3a. Application (#1032571) for a revocable consent for a new unenclosed sidewalk cafe from Maurello, Inc., 447 Third Avenue with 8 tables and 16 seats

Tim McGinn introduced the resolution. Ted Lynn recommended that there be a negative resolution. Ellen Imbimbo said that the restaurant has existed for 20 years and has been a presence in the community. Gary Papush suggested that the resolution include details explaining the Board's opposition. John Pettit West III said that he agreed with Mr. Papush. Mr. McGinn read the three conditions that were amended by the Committee and added to
the resolved.

WHEREAS, the applicant and the applicant's architect came to the Business and Government Committee meeting to discuss this application and answer any questions the committee or the community may have; and

WHEREAS, there were no attendees from the community at large to notify the Board of any complaints or concerns arising from their request for this application; and

WHEREAS, the applicant is willing to change his plans from 8' of sidewalk clearance to 9'; and

WHEREAS, this would be a one-year experiment and the applicant has been in business at this restaurant
for over 21 years; and

WHEREAS, the applicant has advised us of sanitation pick-ups which will not interfere with street traffic; and

WHEREAS, the applicant has advised us that waitperson service will be performed entirely inside the partitioned area; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six opposes the application by Maurello, Inc. for this new unenclosed cafe unless the application is changed to include:

I . a 10-foot clearance on the sidewalk

2. a reduction to 4 tables and 8 seats
3. a 3 -foot aisle between tables.

PASSED: 35 IN FAVOR, 4 OPPOSED, AND 0 ABSTENTIONS

3b. Application (M6-037) for a Street Activity permit from The Black Sheep Restaurant on behalf of the NYPD Widows and Orphans Fund on Saturday, September 16th on East 38th Street between 2nd and 3rd Avenues

Carol Schachter introduced the resolution.

WHEREAS, this is considered a minor street fair and is for a very worthy cause; and

WHEREAS, the applicant will be present at a public hearing and will bring representatives from the
NYPD to outline how these funds will be disbursed; and

WHEREAS, the applicant has advised us that there will be vending activity but no solicitation of funds on
the day of this event; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six supports the street activity permit for the date and time specified.

PASSED: 38 IN FAVOR, 0 OPPOSED, AND 0 ABSTENTIONS

3c. Application (#1034243) from STS Restaurant Corp., 505 Third Avenue (34-35th Streets) for a revocable consent for a new unenclosed sidewalk café with 5 tables and 10 seats.

Tim McGinn introduced the resolution. He said that the Committee voted unanimously.

WHEREAS, the applicant and the applicant's architect came to the Business and Government Committee meeting to discuss this application and answer any questions the committee or the community may have; and

WHEREAS, there were no attendees from the community at large to notify the Board of any complaints or concerns arising from their request for this application; and

WHEREAS, the Committee learned that the 5 tables measure 18 x 24" with a small rail as a partition; and

WHEREAS, there would be sidewalk clearance of 11'8" on the south side and 10'2" on the north side
which more than meets CB6 sidewalk cafe guidelines; and

WHEREAS, the applicant has advised us of sanitation pick-ups which will not interfere with street traffic: and

WHEREAS, the applicant has advised us that waitperson service will be performed entirely inside the
small railing; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six supports the application by STS for this unenclosed sidewalk
cafe.

PASSED: 31 IN FAVOR, 5 OPPOSED, AND 2 ABSTENTIONS
3d. Application (M6-034) for a Street Activity Permit by The New York Fun Factory on behalf of A&E Television Network for August 11, 2000 on East 45th Street between 2nd and 3rd Avenues

Carol Schachter introduced the resolution.

WHEREAS, the applicant has specified that the event will be held only on the sidewalk and that they are
not asking for the street to be closed on the day of the event; and

WHEREAS, the event will be held from 9:00 A.M. to 12:00 P.M. only; and

WHEREAS, this event is a "Corporate Kids Day" which will be of benefit to the community at large; and

WHEREAS, the applicant is not vending nor soliciting funds during this event; and

WHEREAS, this is considered to be a minor street fair, especially given the sidewalk only traffic as
outlined above; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six supports the street activity permit for the date and time specified.

PASSED: 34 IN FAVOR, 3 OPPOSED, AND 2 ABSTENTIONS

3e. Application (M6-035) from Gramercy Neighborhood Associates for a Street Activity Permit on Gramercy Park West between East 20th and East 21st Streets on October 14, 2000 (Rain Date:
October 15, 2000)

WHEREAS, Gramercy Neighborhood Associates has requested a Street Activity Permit in order to conduct their annual Dog Walk; and

WHEREAS, there will be no fund raising, nor will vendors be present; and

WHEREAS, this event is sponsored by an organization indigenous to and part of the fabric of the Gramercy Park community; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six supports the application from Gramercy Neighborhood Associates for a Street Activity Permit for their annual Fall Festival-Dog Walk.

PASSED: 37 IN FAVOR, 0 OPPOSED, I ABSTENTION AND I PRESENT BUT NOT ELIGIBLE TO VOTE

3f. Street Activity Permit Application (M6-033) by the Diocese of the Armenian Church, for its One World Festival, on Saturday, September 9th and Sunday, September 10th, 2000 on East 35th Street and East 36th Street, between First and Second Avenues

WHEREAS, an application for a street activity permit has been received from the Diocese of the Armenian Church for Saturday, September 9th and Sunday, September 10th, on East 35th Street and East 36h Street, between First and Second Avenues; and

WHEREAS, this event is the Diocese's One World Festival; and

WHEREAS, this activity is 'in accordance with the Board Six guidelines, being produced by volunteers and occupying side street locations; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, Community Board Six supports the granting of a Street Activity Permit for the date and location shown above.

PASSED: 38 IN FAVOR, I OPPOSED, AND 0 ABSTENTION

3g. Street Activity Permit Application (M6-036) by the Japan Society for Sunday September 24, 2000 (Rain Date: Sunday, October 1, 2000) on East 47th Street between First and Second Avenues

Someone asked if this was the group that sold their air rights to Trump. There was some grumbling. By a show of hands the resolution passed.

WHEREAS, an application for a street activity permit has been submitted by the Japan Society for Sunday, September 24, 2000 on East 47th Street between First and Second Avenue, and

WHEREAS, this organization will not be fund raising at this activity, and

WHEREAS, this organization will be educating and entertaining the community about the Japan Society, and

WHEREAS, the Japan Society has assured Board Six that it will limit the event to north of the park on East 47th Street.

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, Community Board Six supports the application by the Japan Society for the date and location above.

PASSED: 32 IN FAVOR, 6 OPPOSED, AND 1 ABSTENTION

3h. Application (M6-038) from Sutton Place Synagogue to Install a Sukkah on the public sidewalk at 225 East 51st Street from September 21 to October 3, 2000

John Pettit West III asked when the Sukkah would be returned to the roof Carol Pieper said that the Synagogue has told the Board Office that it would be next year. Carol Schachter confirmed that statement.

WHEREAS, an application for a street activity permit has been received from the Sutton Place Synagogue foiled of 14 days from Tuesday, October 10th through Monday October 23 d at 225 East 51st Street, between per Second and Third Avenues; and

WHEREAS, the Sutton Place Synagogue wishes to build a Sukkah on the sidewalk of East 51st Street; and

WHEREAS, the structure covers the entire width of the sidewalk and causes some pedestrian
inconvenience; and

WHEREAS, the community is generally in favor of this symbolic event and the synagogue has a long
history in the Board area; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six supports the application by the Sutton Place Synagogue for a street activity for the period and location shown above.

PASSED: 33 IN FAVOR, 6 OPPOSED, AND 0 ABSTENTIONS

3i. Application (M6-039) for a Street Activity Permit by Phipps Houses on behalf of Bellevue South Park on Saturday, August 26, 2000 on Mount Carmel Place between East 26th and East 28th Streets

WHEREAS, the applicant is applying for a Saturday event on a minor street between First and Second Avenues; and

WHEREAS, Community Board Six realizes the need for funds to be used for Bellevue South Park; and

WHEREAS, this event will be a block party which will benefit Bellevue South Park as well as the community; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six supports the application for the above street activity for the date requested.

PASSED: 38 IN FAVOR, 0 OPPOSED, 0 ABSTENTIONS, AND I PRESENT BUT NOT ELIGIBLE TO VOTE

3j. Applications to Department of Information Technology and Telecommunications (DOITT) for installation of public pay telephones.

Tim McGinn explained that DOITT has received applications from four companies to install 476 phones. Gary Papush said he could not believe the amount of applications considering the increased usage of cell phones. Ellen Imbimbo offered a friendly amendment to indicate that the Board objects to the limited time given to review the applications. She also suggested that the Board indicate that applicants must show demonstrated need. Mr.
McGinn said that he thought that "need" would be difficult to determine. Lyle Frank and others said that there
was no need for that many additional pay phones. Robert Simmeljkaer asked if these phones were new or
replacing existing ones. Carol Pieper replied that they were new phones. The Committee accepted the friendly amendment regarding insufficient time to review materials.

WHEREAS, four City-franchised pay telephone companies have submitted proposals to install 476 new public pay telephones at locations within Community Board Six, Manhattan; and

WHEREAS, those public pay telephones which have been installed most recently have been housed in
kiosks which are far larger than those utilized in the past and are so designed primarily for the purpose of displaying advertising on public sidewalks; and

WHEREAS, it is anticipated that many if not all of the 476 proposed public telephones will be housed in similarly oversized kiosks; and

WHEREAS, these oversized kiosks occupy an unnecessarily large proportion of the available sidewalk
width and obstruct pedestrian traffic; and

WHEREAS, there has been no demonstrated need for any additional public pay telephones within this
Community Board; and

WHEREAS, the increasingly widespread use of cellular telephones will diminish the need for public pay telephones in the future; and

WHEREAS, a primary purpose of installing these proposed new pay telephones on public streets is to generate additional advertising revenue for the franchise holders; and

WHEREAS, these telephone kiosks have prompted numerous complaints to this Community Board by individuals and community organizations because of their intrusion upon the public sidewalks; and

WHEREAS, insufficient time was given to the Community Board to review the applications individually; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six, Manhattan, opposes the application for installation of all 476 proposed public pay telephones, unless they are installed in kiosks or other structures of minimal width and depth, because they will obstruct pedestrian traffic solely for the purpose of generating advertising revenue and without any benefit to the community; and

BE IT FURTHER

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six, Manhattan, opposes the application because the widespread placement of these oversized structures upon public sidewalks will severely detract from the beauty of the community.

PASSED: 34 IN FAVOR, 4 OPPOSED, AND 1 ABSTENTION

Carol Schachter gave a brief preview of the agenda for the next Committee meeting in August.

PARKS, RECREATION AND CULTURAL AFFAIRS

4a. Application for a distinctive sidewalk in front of 56-58 Park Avenue (37-38 Sts) Proposed Scandinavian House

Sylvia Friedman reported that this was a joint resolution with Transportation. She thanked Lou Sepersky for
writing the resolution on the distinctive sidewalk.

WHEREAS, the developers of Scandinavian House, 56-58 Park Avenue, in Community Board Six, Manhattan, have proposed to use Norwegian alta quartzite, in flamed natural cleft finish, a decorative
paving material; and

WHEREAS, representatives of the developer stated this material meets or exceeds the dry and wet traction (slip resistance) standards of the New York City Department of Transportation; and

WHEREAS, the plans for this building call for use of this material along the approximately 22 foot length, and about one foot width within the building line, and a section six feet square 'in the public sidewalk; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, that Community Board Six, Manhattan, offers no objection to the use of Norwegian alta quartzite, in flamed natural cleft finish, a decorative sidewalk material, on a six foot square portion of the public sidewalk in front of Scandinavian House, 56-58 Park Avenue, on the assurance of the developer that this paving material meets or exceeds the dry and wet traction (slip resistance) standards of the New York City Department of Transportation.

PASSED: 38 in Favor, 1 Opposed, and 0 Abstentions

4b To support continued existence of the Art Commission

Sylvia Friedman thanked Jack Taylor and Gary Papush for writing the resolution on the Art Commission.

WHEREAS, legislation has been introduced into the City Council which would eliminate the New York City Art Commission; and

WHEREAS, The Art Commission was established in 1898 to review and approve the works of art, architecture, and landscape architecture on or over city owned property; and

WHEREAS, The Commission focuses on making design more attractive, cost-effective and suitable for
the proposed neighborhood or setting; and

WHEREAS, 85% of all U.S. cities have followed New York's lead and established their own art commissions; and

WHEREAS, elimination of the agency would leave no review procedure for these projects or chance for Community Board oversight, particularly projects for NYC parks; now

THEREFORE, be it

RESOLVED, Community Board Six opposes passage of Intro. 756 by the City Council.

PASSED: 39 in Favor, 0 Opposed, and 0 Abstentions

Betty Schwartz asked for clarification on how much additional funding was needed to complete the Stuyvesant
Cove project because she remembered hearing that the original projections were beyond the $500,000 that have
been secured. Sylvia Friedman said that EDC agreed to the amount. However, Ms. Friedman said that the specs were not final, and so the cost of expenses have not been finalized. Ms. Friedman also reported that EDC only
invited two Committee members to the presentation by one of the RFP applicants. Steve Rosen and she went. Another presentation was scheduled for July 20th. Bill Oddo expressed frustration that a bid breakdown was not provided and urged the Board to make a concerted effort to get the information. Ms. Friedman explained that Mr.
Rosen and Mr. Barrett have made formal requests. Martin Barrett said that the response he received was that the contractors would spend up to the bid amount. Mr. Oddo suggested that the Board consider filing a Freedom of Information request. A few others agreed with the FOIL idea. Edward Rubin said that he agreed as well and that information about design concepts and maintenance and the like should be available to the public. Mr. Rubin also said that he thought it was egregious that EDC did not invite the entire Committee to the presentations by selected
applicants, considering that the Committee has been working on this project since its inception. Mr. Rubin also pointed out that the RFP did not include the approximately $200,000 for maintenance. Ms. Friedman added that
she is concerned that the park seems to be an adjunct to the environmental center rather than vice versa. Lou Sepersky suggested that a concise letter be sent to EDC stating that the Board would file a FOIL should the information requested not be furnished immediately. Peter Doukas recommended that Sen. Goodman and Asm. Ravitz be contacted for assistance. Someone asked about the time frame for the project. Ms. Friedman said that
Steve Rosen was told that it would be completed as planned. She also reported that the fence at Stuyvesant Square would be repaired by the end of the summer. Unfortunately, the fence at St. Gauden was recently ruined by a taxi cab. Ms. Friedman announced that the next Committee meeting would be held at the Beth Israel bridge. They will take a tour of the bridge and meet with representatives from the hospital thereafter to talk about the bridge design.

HUMAN SERVICES

Deborah Kaplan reported that the State is seeking to divest ownership of some of its property in the City. The
Moravian Church/Open Door is a tenant in state-owned property. Ms. Kaplan spoke to Senator Duane who said
that he would consider advocating the sale of such property to the Church. Ms. Kaplan said that the Committee would draft a letter asking for more information and intends to schedule a site visit with a representative from Senator Duane's office. There are many issues involved, including separation of church and state. The Committee will study the issue more carefully before making a decision. Grand Central Social Services was supposed to be at the last Committee meeting but they did not show. A letter was sent to Brady Crain, of GCSS, requesting his attendance at the next meeting. The Committee has invited the new chair of the Cabrini Dementia Program to an upcoming meeting. Sylvia Friedman suggested the Committee investigate two issues: MCI applications at Peter Cooper and the concrete attack on 29th Street where the NYPD searched shelters in the district for the suspect. Ms. Kaplan said the MCI issue will be put on the agenda. As for the other issue, she said that she would get input
from shelter facilities and Mr. Arcaro. Ms. Kaplan announced that the Nominating Committee has decided to conduct interviews with Board Chair applicants on August 9th. She asked that anyone interested in a position send
a letter of interest, a resume, and cover letter to the Board Office to her attention. The slate would be announced at the September meeting.

YOUTH AND EDUCATION

Maxine McIntosh reported that the CFE vs. NYS case was scheduled for July 27th. The State would deliver their closing argument at 10AM. CFE would give theirs at 2PM. Sylvia Friedman asked if the Committee would discuss Sen. Duane's work-study issue. Ms. McIntosh said that she intended to talk to Sen. Duane about that and other matters. She also announced that the next Committee meeting would Thursday, September 7th.

PUBLIC SAFETY, ENVIRONMENT, AND HUMAN RIGHTS

Fred Arcaro, thanked Steve Portnoy for giving the Committee report in his absence the previous month. He announced that the next meeting would be on September 25th.

OLD/NEW BUSINESS

Peter Doukas said that he recently moved into an apartment overlooking the FDR and the sound is horrible. Bill
Oddo explained that concrete was used on the FDR surface, as opposed to other materials that absorb sound better. Mr. Oddo said that while the FDR received federal funding it did not conduct studies that would have prevented the noise pollution. Fred Arcaro said that issue could be something that his committee would work on jointly with the Transportation Committee.

Second Roll Call

Carol A. Schachter read the roll call.

Adjournment

There being no further business before the Board, the meeting was adjourned.