The HOA is absolutely doing its job, however at some point previous management companies got us into a HUGE hole of debt. So, the HOA has had a hard task of slowly but surely digging its way out. They have done a fabulous job, but now there is the task of now that we HAVE enough money to do things, getting them done and things have to be done in phases or people complain about $200K being dropped. So, the common walls have been repainted and a nice dark stripe put on it to make it look nicer. Gravel is being trucked in (which is evident along Castlegate to the east of the school) and laid out (and this will continue over a period of time), we have great landscapers that are slowly but surely working with the HOA and management company to improve our common areas and fix problem areas that had not been fixed previously. Our weed problem is pretty well under control, they have redone some of the tot lots to improve them and will be starting a huge project on the activity park soon. They have installed solar lights at most, if not all, of the mailboxes to aid in lighting issues for folks.
But, then yes we have kids that want to destroy things like lights and the picket fence along Schnepf and Ocotillo that the HOA (i.e. the RESIDENTS) have to pay to repair (and it is not cheap).
The HOA does a great job, but it is playing "catch up" and where people seem to want things done overnight, that just isn't possible with a subdivision this large, so things are done in stages. I think by the end of 2012 things will be looking a lot nicer and by the end of 2013, even better still. But, as with most things, it is a work in progress.
I think homes in this area in general are hard to sell because nobody wants to make the commute from here to Phoenix, Tempe, etc. We got hit HARD in the housing market for many reasons, so houses are not terribly easy to sell out there, but they're not any more difficult to sell in Castlegate IMO than in any other subdivision in the STV/Queen Creek area.
No, Providence is NOT standing behind their work. Most of the homeowners have had to repair it themselves at their own cost as far as I understand it. As I understand it, the plumber they used has gone out of business so Providence is dragging their feet. Not sayign Providence is better or worse than any other builder, truth be told, I'd imagine you'd find any other builder doing the exact same thing. But, after seeing the issues that these folks have had, I am not sure I'd personally want to purchase a Providence home, however it's only been in certain lot areas. So, the lots that you're looking at may be just fine who knows.