is this better for you nedl. give up liberties for security and we will have neither! welcome to the american police state!your dictator will be G.W Bush. you have the right to do exactly what we say and you won't get hurt!
Free Speech Behind the Razor Wire
Mark Baard
07.27.04
BOSTON -- The estimated 5,000 protesters at the Democratic National Convention this week have so far bumped heads over their political differences. In some cases, they have even barred one another from their scheduled (and permitted) events.
But activists have been largely united in one civil action: their boycott of the so-called free-speech zone carved out by the U.S. Secret Service and local authorities, the only spot where protesters will be able to shout their messages to the delegates arriving on buses in a nearby parking lot.
The protesters are also coordinating actions outside the free-speech zone by sending text messages on their wireless phones. Some protesters for a short time Monday converted the zone into a mock prison camp by donning hoods and marching in the cage with their hands behind their backs.
The protest zone, which most people here simply call "the cage," is beneath an elevated section of disused subway tracks near a newly paved bus parking lot.
Activists say the zone resembles the U.S. prison camp in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and the notorious Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq.
The zone, surrounded by two layers of chain link fences mounted on Jersey barriers, draped with black mesh and topped with razor wire, violates the protesters' free-speech rights, said a legal observer for the Boston chapter of the National Lawyers Guild.
"You can't have free speech inside a prison," said the observer, Tony Naro, a recent college graduate who plans to start law school this fall.
Observers like Naro attend rallies and marches to record incidents where the authorities appear to be violating the protesters' constitutional rights.
Naro noted that when the Boston Police union was planning to protest at the DNC over a contract dispute with Boston Mayor Thomas Menino, "there was no talk of putting them into a free-speech zone. It's the people with the guns who get to have free speech."
On Tuesday, a sole, potbellied protester shouted into a microphone on a makeshift stage provided by the city. Right-to-lifers also crashed the place and covered the area with anti-abortion slogans, thinking the area would see more foot traffic.
But audience members, who have been almost exclusively reporters and photographers, must stand in the line of sight of the loudspeakers mounted along the steel beams overhead. Delegates on the other side of the fence will have a hard time hearing anything.
The Black Tea Society, an anarchist group, as well as the National Lawyers Guild and the American Civil Liberties Union, have all sued to either uncage the free-speech zone, or move it closer to the delegates. But all of those efforts failed, and "the fence stays," said Boston Police Department spokeswoman Beverly Ford.
Anarchists are also wary of being tracked by the cameras mounted in the cage. Most have gotten the message, through wireless text messaging, websites and word of mouth, to avoid the cage and the surrounding Boston Police-patrolled "soft zone," which is immediately outside the "hard zone," an area controlled by the uniformed division of the Secret Service.
Cameras, monitored in Washington, D.C., by the Department of Homeland Security, can be seen on many street corners in the soft zone.
Protesters will thus be scarce through the soft zone.
Published on Tuesday, July 1, 2008 by Rocky Mountain News (Colorado)
Protest Zone Far Cry From Pepsi Center, ACLU Says New Suit Claims Delegates Won't Hear Activities
by Sara Burnett
DENVER - The designated protest zone at the Democratic National Convention will be more than two football fields away from the Pepsi Center - a revelation that drew new legal challenges Monday from the American Civil Liberties Union.
The ACLU, which represents 13 protest groups, says the site effectively denies protesters their right to free speech because delegates and others attending the DNC won't be able to see or hear them.
According to a map released by the city late last week, the protest zone will be in the southern corner of Lot A, about 700 feet from the Pepsi Center. In some places, the view of the building's main doors is obstructed by trees and sculptures.
"No human voice, or any other sound . . . can ever hope to reach a person at the entrance," lawyers for the ACLU wrote in an amended complaint filed in federal court in Denver.
But Denver city attorney David Fine said the city is confident people in the area "will be within sight and sound of the delegates."
The location of the protest zone is significant to demonstrators because most of the area closest to the Pepsi Center, including adjacent sidewalks and streets, will be closed to the public for security reasons.
In a complaint filed in federal court, the ACLU is asking U.S. District Judge Marcia Krieger to order the city and the Secret Service to locate the protest zone, which will be surrounded by a wire mesh fence, closer to the Pepsi Center.
Krieger has scheduled a trial for July 29 - less than a month before the convention starts - to settle that and other issues raised by the ACLU. Krieger was also asked to:
* Bar authorities from searching people entering the protest zone unless police have probable cause, or from declaring that police have the right to search anyone in the protest area.
The city has not said how it will handle searches, but Fine said Monday that, "Simply put, we are going to abide by the Constitution."
* Allow protesters to hand out leaflets to people attending the convention who are within the secured perimeter of the Pepsi Center. The city has said this will be prohibited.
* Allow parades to pass near the Pepsi Center and at times when delegates are present.
The city's approved parade route runs from near Civic Center, west on Colfax Avenue and north on Speer Boulevard to Lari mer Street. People may then walk through the Auraria campus to Seventh Street and Auraria Parkway, which is the entry and exit point for the protest zone in Parking Lot A.
It does not include Chopper Circle or Ninth Street adjacent to the Pepsi Center as the protest groups want, and the route through the campus will not accommodate floats or vehicles.
The city is allowing parades only between 10 a.m. and 3 p.m. Convention organizers have said delegates will arrive at the Pepsi Center each day around 3 p.m., about an hour before the convention program begins.
* Approve alternate parade routes for two groups. One group wants to hold an immigration parade that would start at 29th Street and Speer Boulevard and run south to Sunken Gardens park. The other wants to march from Civic Center to the federal courthouse at 18th and Stout streets to urge the release of "political prisoners." The city has denied both requests.
City officials and the Secret Service have said they must balance the rights of people to express themselves with the need for security during the DNC, scheduled for Aug. 25-28.
They insist the public will still have ample opportunity to communicate with the delegates and others attending the convention, whether it's outside the Pepsi Center or at events scheduled throughout the city.
|
"The word is to avoid any area that is fenced in," said Naro.